Yesterday (before going up to the cottage), several people had copied on facebook a little thing about how Easter is actually named after the ancient Assyrian Goddess Ishtar, goddess of sex and fertility and stuff like that, and the eggs and the rabbit are symbols thereof. Then, today, I found this, from a site called The Belle Jar.
Well, it ticked me off for a couple of reasons. First, she said it came from the page of “noted misogynist and eugenics enthusiast Richard Dawkins.” I am a supporter of Dawkins because, seriously, we’ve got few enough atheist spokespeople out there and that’s what he’s really drawing flak for. He’s not a “noted misogynist,” he’s a “noted atheist” and people who don’t like him say he’s a misogynist. I don’t know. Never met the guy. And eugenics gets a bad rap because the Nazis believed in it, but there are degrees to these things. When eugenics is used to mean “consciously trying to improve the future of the human race by paying attention to breeding” it is a very positive idea. I married a smart woman because (among other reasons, obvs) I wanted smart kids. Cows and pigs have made far more evolutionary headway over the last 200 years or so than human beings have, and it’s all down to breeding. But when eugenics means breeding a blonde haired, blue eyed master race and killing everybody else (which I’m sure Richard Dawkins has never suggested) it’s a very bad thing.
The other reason it ticked me off, though, I must confess, is that it debunked something I had swallowed whole. As I read through her piece (I’m assuming that a site called The Belle Jar is written by a woman), looking for things to attack her with (because I do that), I realized that her basic premise is probably correct. Easter is probably not named after Ishtar, and we really have no idea how that was pronounced, because we weren’t there and there were no recording devices.
However (and she doesn’t disagree with this), Easter is a co-opting of ancient pagan festivals by Christianity (and quite possibly named after the Goddess Eostre). Of course, there is going to be a Spring festival. It’s the end of winter, flowers are blooming, creatures who lay eggs are laying eggs, and rabbits (and sheep, and many other animals) are having babies. Humans can be born at any time. Many animal babies are born in spring, so they will be able to consume lots of grass and get big and fat before winter.
One thing she said that I strongly disagreed with was “Most Christians…. know that Jesus wasn’t really born on December 25th, and they know that there were never any actual snakes in Ireland, and they know that rabbits and eggs are fertility symbols.” Certainly not the Christians I’ve been hearing from. They believe that Noah’s Ark is a true story, that the Earth is only 6,000 years old, and that we atheists are waging a war on Christmas, because it’s Jesus’ birthday and that’s that.
Still, she was right about more than she was wrong about and I give her credit.




