Category Archives: Blogs' Archive

Anonymous or Not

The Huffington Post, which is  my major source of news and perhaps that’s laziness on my part but despite their journalistic shortcomings they cover an incredibly wide range of stuff and have an active commenting community, are changing their comments policy.

The Central Scrutinizer, Arianna Huffington

The Central Scrutinizer, Arianna Huffington

They say that you can’t be anonymous any more, but I’m not really clear what they mean by that since they also said in the same article that it won’t affect people who are already commenting, and I don’t see how both of those can be true, especially those of us who are commenting anonymously now.

But I think maybe they mean “anonymous to the HP,” in other words you can still use a pseudonym, just that the moderators need to know who you are in real life.  I thought that was already the case, but what do I know.

We will see what happens, but the announcement was nowhere near as clear-cut and sharply defined as the reaction to it, which was swift and overwhelmingly negative, with people threatening to quit in droves and I think quite a few of them quitting in reality.  That strikes me as jumping the gun, but everybody chooses for themselves.

They say it’s to get rid of trolls, which is sort of a loose term.  You call me a troll, I say I’m stating a legitimate opinion.  But I can see the point.  There are shit-stirrers, there are trouble makers, and people might be less inclined to post stupid but provocative comments if somebody actually knows who they are and where they live.

On the other hand, it could have a chilling effect on the dialogue, discouraging some of the more radical (i.e. more interesting) ideas.

Personally, I think they would be better served by hiring a few more moderators (stop being a bloody cheapskate, Arianna –  it’s not as if you ever had to work for the money or anything) and paying more attention to the comments, because somebody can be a troll on one subject, on one day, in one particular mood, and otherwise a brilliant and insightful person.

It should be about the comment, not the commenter.

Leave a comment

Filed under Blogs' Archive

Washington Post Apologizes for Wrong Thing

I don’t know if this is the new Jeff Bezos Washington Post or if this is still the old management Washington Post, but they issued an interesting apology today.

Today, on the 50th anniversary of Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream Speech,” the Washington Post admitted they got it wrong – they covered the demonstration, but didn’t actually headline the speech.

It was 50 years ago today

It was 50 years ago today

I forgive them for that.  The fact that Martin Luther King, Jr. delivered a speech on that day was not really news.  He was the scheduled speaker.  The huge numbers of people there was newsworthy, and there were plenty of photos of big crowds.  The fact that the demonstrations were peaceful probably sold fewer newspapers than if they had turned violent, but peaceful they were and the Post reported it correctly.

There was no way to predict, at the time, that the speech would be the thing that people remembered from that day.  Since they are a newspaper and not a future prediction service, they’ve got nothing to apologize for – in this case.

They do owe everybody – both  in the U.S. and Iraq and around the world – a big type, boldfaced apology  for co-operating with the Bush administration to feed the public a steady stream of lies in the run-up to the Iraq War.  That was not a question of failing to understand what would be important in the future, which everybody can be forgiven.  That was about not asking the right questions, that was about believing people they shouldn’t have believed, that was about totally failing to meet their job description, that was dereliction of their duty as journalists, that was complicity in murder and war crimes, that was inexcusable.

Don’t hold your breath waiting for an apology.

Leave a comment

Filed under Blogs' Archive

Touchy, Touchy, Touchy

There were two incidents on facebook today I want to talk about, and there is a link between the two of them, and that link is people being overly fucking sensitive.

The first case, I just can’t figure out how it happened because I’m not sure how facebook works, I guess, so if somebody who reads this could clue me in, that would be great.  Got a post, a harmless post. (are you a genius, can you figure out the next number in the set?)  I respond to those sometimes.

I got the majority answer, which I’m not sure was the only right answer, it doesn’t really matter, it’s not relevant to the story.  After reading the comments for awhile, I happened to look to see who sent the post.   The name seemed familiar.  Right, she defriended me…rather vehemently, I might add…a couple of months ago.  So, I checked to see if somehow we were still friends.  We are not.

I’m not too bothered.  I wasn’t as angry with her as she was with me.  I just can’t figure out how I saw her post.

The original cause of defriending was she went ballistic on some guy on her comment thread and told him to either apologize or fuck off or both and my comment was just “What did he say that was so bad?” and she snapped right back “You aren’t a part of this conversation.”

Oversensitive.  I wasn’t looking for an argument, I was actually trying to be conciliatory.  Also, it seems to me that if you’re posting stuff on facebook, pretty much anybody can be a part of the conversation if they want.oversensitive

The incident today was similar.  A man posted a “sonnet” he’d written, and I put that in quotes because a lot of people say “Oh, look at this sonnet I just wrote” and you look and it isn’t a sonnet at all.  I have a lot of writers on my page, of course, but I’ve heard it at poetry readings, too.  “Here is a sonnet,” and they proceed to recite something which isn’t recognizable as a sonnet at all.

So, I wrote back and said “This is not a sonnet.”  He asked for an explanation and I gave him one, about syllable counts and rhyming and iambic pentameter and all that, and he said “Well, apparently you haven’t heard of modern sonnets, they don’t have to rhyme any more and stop posting, I’m done with this conversation.”

Oversensitive.  But, it inspired me to write this:

A cherry pie is more than just some food

That, by happenstance, has cherries on it

So, when poets ply their poetude

Not every piece they pen is called a sonnet

Of syllables there must be 10 per line

Perhaps eleven if one of them is weak

You might get away with only nine

But ten’s the magic number you should seek

Just 14 lines, or 18 is O.K.

And it must rhyme, like this: AABB

ABAB or else ABBA

You’ve got some choices, any of those three

Iambic meter is the hardest part

But necessary to this form of art

Next time somebody tells me they’ve written a sonnet and they bloody haven’t, they’re going to get a copy.

1 Comment

Filed under Blogs' Archive

Chelsea Manning

Oh, my.  I just don’t know what to make of Bradley, from this point forward to be known as Chelsea, Manning.

On the  one hand, I fully support the right of anybody to be referred to in any way they want to, so if he wants to change his name and be referred to as she, I can live with that.  As a blogger,  it’s a piece of cake to shift the pronouns.

Chelsea Manning

Chelsea Manning

Even the bit about wanting to actually become a woman, well, he’s she’s an adult so who’s going to stop her.  Well, probably the U.S. government for the  next 10 years or so.  That’s a shame, but there it is.

The thing that bothers me about it all is that it’s a merging of plot lines.  He can be either a whistleblowing hero, a 21st century Benedict Arnold, or a guy who wants to get a sex change operation.  Those are three very different stories, and they don’t really mix.  If I saw this in a TV serial, I would be shrieking “Sensationalism!  Bad writing!”

But, there it is.  All my protestations amount to is “This seems strange to me,” and so be it, this is not about me.  Truth is stranger than fiction and this is the Chelsea Manning story now.

One little point I’d like to add is I don’t  think it will affect her levels of support at all.  Those of us who support her are probably mostly cool with the gender-choice issue as well, because we’re liberal; and those who didn’t couldn’t possibly hate  her any more than they already do.

2 Comments

Filed under Blogs' Archive

35 Years Too Long

So, 35 years.  After being held in solitary confinement for a year and denied a trial for almost 3, Bradley Manning still has 35 years to go.  Maybe as low as 8, with good behavior, before he’s eligible for parole.

Could have been worse.  I expected worse.

But the bad thing is that I have been conditioned to accept the intolerable merely on the grounds that it could have been worse, which is totally the result of false negative expectation inflation.  They threaten him with  a million years in prison, we say no, let him go, and when the judge only  gives him 35 years we breathe a sigh of relief.

Bradley Manning

Bradley Manning

It’s like in the shops, when they have a big sale of 50% off, it’s off a price that’s more than twice an acceptable price in the first place.  My wife goes for it, every time.  I’m sure millions of others do, too, because they keep doing it.

But in the case of Bradley Manning, it’s not right.  He reported the guys shooting journalists from helicopters and laughing about it.  For that, he deserves a medal, maybe even a statue.  Not 35 years in jail.  Not even  one year in jail.  They owe Bradley Manning an apology, but they’re digging in.

Oh, sure, lots of other documents were released, too, but in the end, nobody got killed.  That’s the thing.  It’s possible to release 700,000 documents, and all that happens if a couple of ambassadors, who were dumb enough to make disparaging comments about their host countries over the internet, got recalled.

It’s proof positive, in case anybody ever doubted it, that the people who are running the world are incompetent as fuck and classifying everything because they don’t know the difference.

We owe Bradley Manning for that knowledge.  I hope he gets out soon, and eventually gets a full apology.

1 Comment

Filed under Blogs' Archive