What’s Good for Gaza is Good for Israel

I must confess, there are things about the situation in Gaza, and the whole Israeli-Palestinian conflict,  that I don’t understand.  Mostly, I don’t understand how such a tiny region, with no great resources and fewer people than many of the world’s great cities, can so totally dominate world

When walls come down, it's a good thing

political discussion.  If everybody would just ignore them…well, they wouldn’t go away, and they wouldn’t stop fighting, but at least we’d have the pleasure of not dealing with them.

Anyway, I am pleased with the news that the border between Egypt and Gaza is now open, and this touches on another point I don’t understand.  If Gaza is supposed to be the Palestinian state, then how did Israel ever get to enforce a closed border between Gaza and Egypt?  It reinforces the notion, which I had thought was a bit of an exaggeration, that Gaza is not a state, not a homeland, but a big prison.

I am confused about the how, but even more about the why.

With open borders, lots of Palestinians will move to Egypt, or further afield, in search of jobs and a better life.  This removes them from the region and, by extension, from the conflict.  Also, some of these people will send money back into Gaza, which will raise the standard of living.  Higher standard of living, less reason to fight.  Above all, that little bit of freedom, a window on the world, gives the Palestinians hope.  People who have hope, hope for a better future, hope for a better life, do not want to become martyrs.

I understand that the Israeli position is that with an open border, arms will flood in.  Paranoia.  Israel gets billions of dollars a year in military aid from the U.S., has the most modern, high tech air force in the world, an army, a navy and nuclear weapons.  Palestine has none of that.

So, if you are an Israeli who is worried about a randomly aimed, feeble, antiquated rocket hitting your front porch, don’t live near the border with Gaza (which, honestly, is not the most desirable area of Israel to live in, anyway).

In conclusion, the opening of this border is a good thing.  It’s a ray of hope for the Palestinians, the lancing of a small pimple for the Egyptians, and a big reduction in pressure for the Israelis.  The fact that the Israelis don’t know what’s good for them does not need to concern the rest of the world.

3 Comments

Filed under Blogs' Archive

3 responses to “What’s Good for Gaza is Good for Israel

  1. i once heard a comedian say there’s nothing like a holocaust to make you a little paranoid.

  2. I can understand Jewish people who are 90 years old being a bit paranoid. We are talking about their children and their grandchildren and their great-grandchildren. At some point, you’ve got to get over it.

  3. A's avatar A

    I agree that it would be nice if they could all just get along, but there are fundamental issues at play that can’t just be smoothed over. You can’t deal rationally with irrational people and many Palestians are flat out irrational: the belief, contrary to established fact, that the land belongs to them, as if there ever was a Palestinian “state”; or the use of suicide bombers, driven by the promise of eternal rewards. Just a couple of items among many. The lack of peace is largely dependent on the fact that Palestinians don’t want peace.

    The problem of “getting over” things is that people forget. Those who don’t recall their history, or know it in the first place, are doomed to repeat it. The Holocaust is something we’re better off not repeating. As a European, you could travel to Auschwitz or Dachau, which I visited on our trip to Germany, and assail yourself of the history and suffering of such places. As they say, “Never again.”

Leave a reply to donna kuhn Cancel reply